Unsorted FBI Documents

Attachment to Independent Case Review Report
For CDRU # 5866 Case file # 95-230469,

Material Examiner: Malone fRO)

Remarks:

Case resulted in a guilty plea, no testimony transcript.

CRM - 7867

INDEPENDENT CASE REVIEW REPORT

Independent Review conducted by: . Steve Robertson

Area(s) of Expertise: Hair and Fiber

Review commenced at: 10:15 AM (Time), 10/23/02 (Date)

File#: 95-230469

Laboratoiy #(s): 90424020

Examiner(s) & Symbols

Reviewed

Not Reviewed

Reviewed

Not Reviewed

X

a

□

o

D

□

□

□

D

□

□

□

Materials Reviewed

Trial testimony transcripts) of: Not available,, guilty plea

Testimony Date(s): Pages:

Laboratoiy Report(s):

I

Laboratoiy Number: 90424020 Date: Aug. 2, 1979

Laboratoiy Number Date:

Laboratoiy Number Date:

Examiner Bench Notes of: RQ

Laboratoiy Number: 90424020

Page

of

CRM - 7868

Irtifiole'

^ 7 ///

Was any other material reviewed? X Yes □ No

If yes, please identify and/or describe the material: submitting agency letter dated April 13, 1979

Results of Review

File#: 95-230469

Item or Specimen # Reviewed: Q1-Q7, K1-K5

Review ofLaboratory Report(s) and Bench Notes:

1)

2 )

Note: Numbered comments are required below or on
additional pages for any "No" or "Unable to Determine" Responses

Did the examiner perform the appropriate tests in a scientifically acceptable manner, based on the
methods, protocols, and analytic techniques available at the time of the original examination^)?

□ Yes oNo X Unable to Determine

Are the examination results set forth in the laboratoiy report(s) supported and adequately documented in
the bench notes? nYes XNo □ Unable to Determine

Review of Testimony:

Note: Numbered comments are required below or on
additional pages for any "No" or "Unable to Determine" Responses

X Transcript not available.

*

k

3) Testimony consistent with the laboratoiy report(s)?

a Yes

□ No

□ Unable to Determine

4) Testimony consistent with the bench notes?

o Yes

□ No

□ Unable to Determine

5) _ Testimony within bounds of examinees expertise?

a Yes

□ No

n Unable to Determine

Page

2 of 3

Initials;

V •? . »A • • S' * .

" * * : »•*• * * ~ 'v<->

0

Comments

(Set forth by above question #, if applicable. .
Use "Additional Comments" Sheet, if needed)

File#: 95-230469

#1. It cannot be determined from the notes if the tests were performed in a scientifically acceptable manner.

#2. The results are not adequately documented in the notes. The notes are not dated, are in pencil. instead of ink

and use abbreviations difficult to interpret

Review completed at:

10:30 AM (Time), , 10/23/02

(Date)

Total time spent conducting review (to nearest 1/4 hour):

0.25 hrs.

I hereby certify that I conducted this review in an independent, unbiased manner and that the results of my review
are fully documented on this report consisting of a total of 3 pages.

mi,.

(Signature)

Oct 23, 2002